Before the end of last year, I wrote about obtaining trademark protection in a series of works. I used books as an example: while you normally cannot register the title of a single book, when you develop a series of books under the same title, that title develops trademark rights for which you can seek a trademark registration. Similarly, a TV show series can develop rights in the name when several episodes are released. Why do I re-bring this up?
A restaurant opened in Scottsdale not long ago called Twin Peaks. The name brings up some issues. First, there is a very well-known brewery in Tempe and Scottsdale called Four Peaks, named (presumably) after a local mountain with a prominent profile on the horizon (a friend suggested that Twin Peaks might just be half-size Four Peaks). Second, we all know the TV show Twin Peaks. My wife made the connection between the new restaurant and the TV show before she made the connection between the new restaurant and the brewery, which indicates the significance in the likelihood of confusion analysis of the mark’s literal element with respect to the mark’s services. When a mark is famous, identity of a second mark can create confusion even if there is a chasm between the goods and services.
So is there actionable confusion here? Not likely. The restaurant and the TV show are so different that crossover is unlikely. The Trademark Office apparently didn’t think there would be confusion, either. Twin Peaks the TV show is protected with federal trademark registrations – one for “entertainment services in the nature of a dramatic television series” and the other for a “series [note: a series] of video recordings featuring entertainment.” Twin Peaks the restaurant has a few federal registrations, and the Trademark Office didn’t raise the TV show’s marks against any of them during prosecution of the applications.
happenings from this weekend’s
book title are not ordinarily available. Trademark protection doesn’t extend to titles of single pieces. Even massive sales of a single work cannot create the necessary source-indicating quality that a trademark requires. So if your book is a stand-alone piece, you likely cannot protect its title.
the appropriate subject matter to be eligible for a patent. Appropriate subject matter includes, by
a few months ago and saw this sign. Clients frequently have
TV the other day the perfect gift for your favorite trademark attorney or advertising executive. Test their subject matter knowledge with the
crucial when you are trying to understand what a patent is and what it can do for you as an inventor. I recently read in Mechanics of Patent Claim Drafting by John Landis a great, easy-to-comprehend explanation: “A claim is a one-sentence definition of the structure of the defined invention. It defines that invention with the same particularity and precision as the description of a parcel of land in a deed. The analogy to the deed is a good one because United States [patent] claims serve to define the outer limits or boundaries of the invention in the same fashion as the description of land in a deed defines the outer limits of the land monopoly.”
